Mastering for vinyl requires a different approach than when mastering for digital formats such as CD.
Certain frequency ranges need to be kept at bay in order to have a good groove tracking and the phase of the signal needs to be kept in check as well.
Without getting too “nerdy”, mastering for vinyl requires different skills and methodologies, which are acquired by an ME over the years.
Compression and EQ need to be applied within the physical/mechanical limitation that the groove/needle combo suffers from.
In other words, if not prepared carefully, your vinyl master could literally force the needle to jump out of the groove!
As a result, the masters prepared for vinyl sound generally a lot quieter, than the ones mastered for digital media and they are normally delivered at a higher resolution as well (2496).
This is why a CD master should NOT be used to cut a vinyl.
Over the years, here at Swift we prepared hundreds of masters for vinyl and we never got one rejected by the cutting place!